Reversal for France: The ECJ Approves Terms Like "Plant-Based Steak"
The European Court of Justice (ECJ) has ruled against France, prohibiting EU member states from banning the use of animal-related terms for plant-based products. This decision marks a turning point for the meat alternatives industry.
In brief
The ECJ has declared that an EU member state cannot forbid the use of terms such as "plant-based steak" or "vegetarian sausage." France, which had attempted to legislate with two decrees in 2022 and 2024, has been overruled by the European court. These French decrees had already been suspended, pending this decision. The Court ruled that existing EU regulations sufficiently protect consumers from confusion. This decision favors plant-based product manufacturers while posing challenges for traditional meat industry stakeholders.
Analysis and Insights
A win for plant-based alternatives: This decision strengthens the position of vegetarian and vegan products in Europe, giving them the legal right to use terms traditionally associated with meat. It underscores a significant trend: the rise of plant-based alternatives driven by growing demand for healthier and more environmentally friendly products.
A challenge for the meat industry: French animal product producers see this ruling as a direct threat to their efforts to maintain a clear distinction between meat and substitutes. They will need to adapt to this new regulatory landscape, which limits their ability to influence the terminology used for plant-based products.
Cultural and linguistic differences: The ECJ highlights that the definition of terms like "steak" or "sausage" can vary between European countries. This decision may lead to further divergence in local regulations and commercial practices across the EU single market.
Business Opportunity
For plant-based product manufacturers, this ruling is a significant opportunity to strengthen their marketing positioning. Using terms like "steak" or "sausage" allows them to leverage familiar consumer references, making their products more accessible, particularly to flexitarians. This decision also paves the way for harmonized business practices across Europe, facilitating brand expansion beyond national markets.
For the meat industry, this setback complicates the efforts of pro-meat lobbies as they face increasing competition from plant-based alternatives. Meat producers will need to rethink their strategies to differentiate their offerings in a market where plant-based options are increasingly recognized and legitimized.
Alice P